Skip to content 
The summer transfer window is open, and Old Trafford is a hive of activity. With Michael Carrick now at the helm permanently and Casemiro’s departure confirmed, INEOS is wasting no time aggressively rebuilding the Manchester United midfield.
Top sources—including David Ornstein and Fabrizio Romano—have confirmed that United’s first breakthrough of the summer is a €45 million (£38m) deal to sign Éderson from Atalanta. Naturally, the immediate assumption across social media is that the 26-year-old Brazilian international has been bought to plug the defensive hole left by his legendary countryman.
But is that actually the case? Tactical analysts and well-placed insiders are shouting a resounding no. Éderson is not a direct clone of Casemiro, and his arrival does not mean United’s midfield shopping spree is over.
Why Éderson is NOT the Direct Casemiro Replacement
To assume Éderson is arriving to play as a lone, deep-lying number six is to misunderstand how he flourished under Gian Piero Gasperini at Atalanta.
Éderson is a relentless, high-octane box-to-box engine. His greatest strengths lie in his front-footed pressing, his ability to win the ball high up the pitch, and his power to drive transitions forward. He thrives with a dedicated anchor behind him.
Casemiro, even in his later years, was an elite positional defensive midfielder—a traditional screen for the back four. If Carrick intends to play a balanced midfield, he still requires a true, specialist biological defensive anchor. Éderson has been brought in to inject athleticism and energy alongside Kobbie Mainoo, not to sit back and hold the fort alone.
The True Shortlist: Who is Being Chosen for the Pivot?
If Éderson isn’t the direct Casemiro replacement, who is? Behind the scenes, the INEOS recruitment team—led by Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox—has a very specific elite shortlist. It has become clear that the role will ultimately come down to a decision between four highly-rated targets:
| Target | Club | Player Profile | The Catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandro Tonali | Newcastle United | The dream tactical orchestrator. Deep-lying playmaker with elite Premier League experience. | High financial package; intense competition from Manchester City. |
| Carlos Baleba | Brighton | A raw, physically imposing defensive powerhouse with an incredibly high ceiling. | Brighton’s notoriously difficult negotiation tactics. |
| Elliot Anderson | Nottingham Forest | A standout domestic star who offers immense energy, ball retention, and versatile Premier League quality. | A potential “Premier League tax” pushing his valuation towards $100m. He prefers a move to Man City. |
| Aurélien Tchouaméni | Real Madrid | The absolute dream replacement. Elite defensive awareness and European pedigree. | Real Madrid have repeatedly stated he is firmly not for sale. |
If United fail to land one of these premium tactical anchors, the recruitment team may opt for structural continuity with their current squad rather than panicking on a sub-par alternative. It’s a game of elite patient chess.
Who Will Manchester United Sign Next? (All Eyes on Mateus Fernandes)
While the search for a direct number six continues, United’s actual next signing is moving at a much faster pace, and it points directly to West Ham’s highly-rated Portuguese midfielder, Mateus Fernandes.
United have entered advanced territory to secure the 21-year-old Portuguese starlet. Fernandes has put the Premier League on notice with his exceptional technical security, press-resistance, and brilliant creative output.
Rather than a direct defensive replacement, Fernandes represents the future of United’s progression under Carrick. He provides elite depth and tactical flexibility across the central lines, allowing United to compete across both the domestic front and the Champions League. With personal terms moving smoothly, expect Mateus Fernandes to be the next face holding up the red shirt at Carrington.